Welcome!

Related Topics: @CloudExpo, Microservices Expo

@CloudExpo: Article

It’s War: Public vs. Private Cloud Computing

There is a common question that almost universally arises when people discuss cloud computing

There is a common question that almost universally arises when people discuss cloud computing. The question came up in a webinar I did with Rackspace last week. It was featured in regular conversation at Cloud Connect and then again on Twitter from Adrian Cockcroft. The question was framed like;

  • "There is no technical reason for private cloud, it's all $, FUD, and internal politics. Discuss." - Adrian Cockcroft,
  • Do you think there is a need for private clouds (vs. public)?

Important to note we are not talking whether they should run on a cloud. This argument only applies to applications and workloads that have already been determined to be a good fit for cloud.

The second question is more easily answered as it alludes to diverse organizational requirements that are unable to be serviced by a commodity service, or the natural inertia of organizations to adopt new methods. The arguments for adoption of private cloud over public cover a range of topics, including:

  • Trust
  • Service level agreements
  • Security needs
  • Migration costs
  • And many more

The more meaty argument is Adrian's. Is there any "technical reason" for not running on public cloud? This challenges us to try and determine if there are architectural patterns that public clouds cannot provide.

Adrian is royalty in the realm of cloud (I prefer "royalty" because it reflects respect for his achievement and position, instead of the term "clouderati," which reflects some sort of enlightenment), but his question is a little sensational. First of all it is so broad, it's difficult to support or refute. Second, it encompasses the future, for which anything is possible. He blogs in more detail here.

But, for what it's worth, here are my thoughts. Public clouds are designed on one basic premise that differentiates them from a private cloud - "Economies of Scale." Having enough workload running in a multi-tenancy environment will balance out noise in the elasticity of workload and also drive down costs for the operation of the infrastructure. So for a private cloud to exist technically, it needs;

  • Enough volume to have economies of scale internally
  • Workload elasticity to warrant a cloud
  • A specific technical requirement that does not warrant economies of scale publicly

I am an architectural pragmatist. Sometimes the cloud debate gets a bit more religious and I feel more like an atheist or a nihilist. I do believe that infrastructure (compute, storage, network & operating systems) and the workloads it is able to support are sufficiently complex to represent a distribution curve of requirements. The amount that can be served by public clouds represents the meat in the middle of the curve. This curve might have an extremely narrow peak, but the tails still exist.

The argument will be that there are many different public clouds, and they can service a wide range of technical requirements, but I still believe that the underlying architecture patterns are complex enough to reveal patterns that cannot be provided in volume.

The other issue I have with economies of scale solutions is they inherently develop lowest common denominator architecture. The non-technical aspects of public clouds limit their ability to solve for all workloads.

In closing, I will try and give examples of workloads that need private clouds:

  1. Slot machine gaming software - very elastic workload with very specific technical requirements for security, auditability and physical machine interface. I cannot see this being supported by a public cloud.
  2. Online gaming - take a large Facebook-based games company. Lots of elastic workloads, but all with a very close correlation architecturally to each other. They have the economies of scale on their own to get the benefits of efficient operations. I can see them developing a private cloud that is optimized for their unique technical requirements while providing a high degree of automation to get better efficiencies than a public cloud.

In the end, I don't see public vs private cloud as a war. Maybe more of an argument for tolerance and an endorsement of the adage "to each his own".

More Stories By Brad Vaughan

Brad Vaughan is a twenty year veteran consultant working with companies around the globe to transform technology infrastructure to deliver enhanced business services.

Latest Stories
"Storpool does only block-level storage so we do one thing extremely well. The growth in data is what drives the move to software-defined technologies in general and software-defined storage," explained Boyan Ivanov, CEO and co-founder at StorPool, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at 16th Cloud Expo, held June 9-11, 2015, at the Javits Center in New York City.
Sometimes I write a blog just to formulate and organize a point of view, and I think it’s time that I pull together the bounty of excellent information about Machine Learning. This is a topic with which business leaders must become comfortable, especially tomorrow’s business leaders (tip for my next semester University of San Francisco business students!). Machine learning is a key capability that will help organizations drive optimization and monetization opportunities, and there have been some...
A strange thing is happening along the way to the Internet of Things, namely far too many devices to work with and manage. It has become clear that we'll need much higher efficiency user experiences that can allow us to more easily and scalably work with the thousands of devices that will soon be in each of our lives. Enter the conversational interface revolution, combining bots we can literally talk with, gesture to, and even direct with our thoughts, with embedded artificial intelligence, whic...
The question before companies today is not whether to become intelligent, it’s a question of how and how fast. The key is to adopt and deploy an intelligent application strategy while simultaneously preparing to scale that intelligence. In her session at 21st Cloud Expo, Sangeeta Chakraborty, Chief Customer Officer at Ayasdi, provided a tactical framework to become a truly intelligent enterprise, including how to identify the right applications for AI, how to build a Center of Excellence to oper...
While some developers care passionately about how data centers and clouds are architected, for most, it is only the end result that matters. To the majority of companies, technology exists to solve a business problem, and only delivers value when it is solving that problem. 2017 brings the mainstream adoption of containers for production workloads. In his session at 21st Cloud Expo, Ben McCormack, VP of Operations at Evernote, discussed how data centers of the future will be managed, how the p...
ChatOps is an emerging topic that has led to the wide availability of integrations between group chat and various other tools/platforms. Currently, HipChat is an extremely powerful collaboration platform due to the various ChatOps integrations that are available. However, DevOps automation can involve orchestration and complex workflows. In his session at @DevOpsSummit at 20th Cloud Expo, Himanshu Chhetri, CTO at Addteq, will cover practical examples and use cases such as self-provisioning infra...
As DevOps methodologies expand their reach across the enterprise, organizations face the daunting challenge of adapting related cloud strategies to ensure optimal alignment, from managing complexity to ensuring proper governance. How can culture, automation, legacy apps and even budget be reexamined to enable this ongoing shift within the modern software factory? In her Day 2 Keynote at @DevOpsSummit at 21st Cloud Expo, Aruna Ravichandran, VP, DevOps Solutions Marketing, CA Technologies, was jo...
As Marc Andreessen says software is eating the world. Everything is rapidly moving toward being software-defined – from our phones and cars through our washing machines to the datacenter. However, there are larger challenges when implementing software defined on a larger scale - when building software defined infrastructure. In his session at 16th Cloud Expo, Boyan Ivanov, CEO of StorPool, provided some practical insights on what, how and why when implementing "software-defined" in the datacent...
Blockchain. A day doesn’t seem to go by without seeing articles and discussions about the technology. According to PwC executive Seamus Cushley, approximately $1.4B has been invested in blockchain just last year. In Gartner’s recent hype cycle for emerging technologies, blockchain is approaching the peak. It is considered by Gartner as one of the ‘Key platform-enabling technologies to track.’ While there is a lot of ‘hype vs reality’ discussions going on, there is no arguing that blockchain is b...
Blockchain is a shared, secure record of exchange that establishes trust, accountability and transparency across business networks. Supported by the Linux Foundation's open source, open-standards based Hyperledger Project, Blockchain has the potential to improve regulatory compliance, reduce cost as well as advance trade. Are you curious about how Blockchain is built for business? In her session at 21st Cloud Expo, René Bostic, Technical VP of the IBM Cloud Unit in North America, discussed the b...
You know you need the cloud, but you’re hesitant to simply dump everything at Amazon since you know that not all workloads are suitable for cloud. You know that you want the kind of ease of use and scalability that you get with public cloud, but your applications are architected in a way that makes the public cloud a non-starter. You’re looking at private cloud solutions based on hyperconverged infrastructure, but you’re concerned with the limits inherent in those technologies.
Is advanced scheduling in Kubernetes achievable?Yes, however, how do you properly accommodate every real-life scenario that a Kubernetes user might encounter? How do you leverage advanced scheduling techniques to shape and describe each scenario in easy-to-use rules and configurations? In his session at @DevOpsSummit at 21st Cloud Expo, Oleg Chunikhin, CTO at Kublr, answered these questions and demonstrated techniques for implementing advanced scheduling. For example, using spot instances and co...
The use of containers by developers -- and now increasingly IT operators -- has grown from infatuation to deep and abiding love. But as with any long-term affair, the honeymoon soon leads to needing to live well together ... and maybe even getting some relationship help along the way. And so it goes with container orchestration and automation solutions, which are rapidly emerging as the means to maintain the bliss between rapid container adoption and broad container use among multiple cloud host...
The cloud era has reached the stage where it is no longer a question of whether a company should migrate, but when. Enterprises have embraced the outsourcing of where their various applications are stored and who manages them, saving significant investment along the way. Plus, the cloud has become a defining competitive edge. Companies that fail to successfully adapt risk failure. The media, of course, continues to extol the virtues of the cloud, including how easy it is to get there. Migrating...
Imagine if you will, a retail floor so densely packed with sensors that they can pick up the movements of insects scurrying across a store aisle. Or a component of a piece of factory equipment so well-instrumented that its digital twin provides resolution down to the micrometer.