|By PR Newswire||
|June 7, 2013 06:38 PM EDT||
DALLAS, June 7, 2013 /PRNewswire/ -- The Texas Supreme Court ("Court") has upheld a refund of sales taxes paid by a Ryan client on items resold to the United States government. In Combs v. Health Care Services Corporation, Nos. 11-0283, 11-0652 (Tex., June 7, 2013), the Court ruled that Health Care Services Corporation (HCSC), successor to Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas, Inc., could claim a sale-for-resale exemption on tangible personal property and taxable services purchased to fulfill contracts with the federal government to administer Medicare Part A, Medicare Part B, and the Federal Employees Health Benefit Program ("FEP"). The Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts ("Comptroller") denied HCSC's administrative refund claims, and HCSC subsequently filed suit. Mark W. Eidman and Doug Sigel of the Ryan Law Firm, LLP represented HCSC before the Court.
Ryan analyzed the facts and developed HCSC's theories for recovery during the administrative refund process. HCSC sought refunds of Texas sales and use taxes paid on:
- Allowable Items – tangible personal property, such as office supplies and furniture;
- Capitalized Assets – capital assets that HCSC booked as assets, depreciated, and claimed as depreciation expenses to the federal government;
- Utilities – gas and electricity;
- Leases of office equipment, telephones, postage machines, water coolers, etc.;
- Software/Software Maintenance – licenses to use software and maintenance of software;
- Taxable Services on Tangible Personal Property – repairs of equipment, purchases of burglar or fire alarm services; and
- Maintenance on tangible personal property.
HCSC contended that the foregoing items, on which HCSC paid tax at the time of purchase, were actually resold to the federal government under the Medicare and FEP contracts. The contracts contained title-passage provisions incorporated from the Federal Acquisition Regulations (FAR), which generally provided that items purchased for the performance of the contracts became the property of the federal government upon delivery to HCSC. The Court upheld the sale-for-resale exemption on purchases of tangible personal property and taxable services but denied the exemption for leases of tangible personal property.
First, the Court held that HCSC was entitled to the sale-for-resale exemption on purchases of tangible personal property that was automatically transferred to the federal government under the title passage provisions. The Comptroller presented the Court with a novel interpretation of the "essence of the transaction" test, contending that the sale-for-resale exemption did not apply because HCSC's "primary purpose" in buying property was to use it in the performance of nontaxable services and not to resell it in the form or condition in which it was acquired. The Court rejected this argument because it is not supported by the plain language of the statute.
Furthermore, the Court reaffirmed its earlier decision in Day & Zimmerman, Inc. v. Calvert, 519 S.W.2d 106 (Tex. 1975). The Court held that the title transfer provisions at issue in Day & Zimmerman are indistinguishable from those in the present case and that subsequent changes in the law neither modified nor abrogated Day & Zimmerman. The Court held that "Day & Zimmerman cuts squarely in HCSC's favor" and "stands for the proposition that automatic title transfer upon purchase qualifies for the sale-for-resale exemption."
The Court rejected the Comptroller's argument that "absurd" consequences would flow from a ruling in favor of HCSC. The Comptroller pointed out that a provider of a taxable service may issue a resale certificate only for the purchase of tangible personal property that will be transferred to the care, custody, and control of the purchaser of the service, whereas the provider of a nontaxable service (such as HCSC) could claim the exemption under automatic title transfer provisions in its contracts. First, the Court noted that "absurdity" is an issue only if a statute is ambiguous and that there is nothing "absurd" about treating providers of taxable and nontaxable services differently. The Court wrote that even "odd" or unexpected results do not compel it to rewrite an unambiguous law. The Court said that the Legislature has had decades since Day & Zimmerman to close this alleged "loophole" but has not done so.
Next, the Court held that HCSC's purchases of taxable services also qualified for the sale-for-resale exemption. The Comptroller argued that the title transfer provisions applied only to tangible personal property. The Court responded that HCSC acquired taxable services and resold them to the government "by directing that they be performed on the government's behalf with the purpose of receiving reimbursement and compensation (consideration) from the government…" Such services were resold "in the form or condition" in which they were acquired. Therefore, they qualified for the exemption under the plain language of the statute.
The Court denied the sale-for-resale exemption for HCSC's leases of tangible personal property. Although the Court acknowledged that a lease of property for the purpose of re-leasing it would qualify for the sale-for-resale exemption, it held that there was no evidence that HCSC re-leased property to the federal government. Using the property to perform nontaxable services under a federal contract was not the same as "formally re-leasing" the property to the government. The subsequent transfer of leased property to a new contractor after the expiration of HCSC's contract was insufficient to establish that HCSC originally leased the property for the purpose of re-leasing it, as required by the exemption.
Finally, the Comptroller argued that HCSC could not obtain a refund because the government reimbursed HCSC for the sales taxes it paid to its suppliers. The Comptroller relied on Tex. Tax Code section 111.104(f), which provides that "[n]o taxes…may be refunded to a person who has collected the taxes from another person unless the person has refunded all the taxes and interest to the person from whom the taxes were collected." The Court held that "reimbursement" and "collection" of taxes are two different things, and HCSC did not "collect" taxes from the federal government within the meaning of the statute.
The Court remanded the case to the trial court for entry of judgment based upon these holdings. At press time, it was not known whether the Comptroller would ask the Court to reconsider.
Ryan is an award-winning global tax services firm, with the largest indirect tax practice in North America and the seventh largest corporate tax practice in the United States. Headquartered in Dallas, Texas, the Firm provides a comprehensive range of state, local, federal, and international tax advisory and consulting services on a multi-jurisdictional basis, including audit defense, tax recovery, credits and incentives, tax process improvement and automation, tax appeals, tax compliance, and strategic planning. Ryan is a three-time recipient of the International Service Excellence Award from the Customer Service Institute of America (CSIA) for its commitment to world-class client service. Empowered by the dynamic myRyan work environment, which is widely recognized as the most innovative in the tax services industry, Ryan's multi-disciplinary team of more than 1,600 professionals and associates serves over 9,000 clients in 40 countries, including many of the world's most prominent Global 5000 companies. More information about Ryan can be found at www.ryan.com.
TECHNICAL INFORMATION CONTACTS:
Randy W. Donald
Ginny Buckner Kissling
John D. Christian
SOURCE Ryan, LLC
20th Cloud Expo, taking place June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY, will feature technical sessions from a rock star conference faculty and the leading industry players in the world. Cloud computing is now being embraced by a majority of enterprises of all sizes. Yesterday's debate about public vs. private has transformed into the reality of hybrid cloud: a recent survey shows that 74% of enterprises have a hybrid cloud strategy.
Dec. 2, 2016 11:15 PM EST Reads: 1,669
"Once customers get a year into their IoT deployments, they start to realize that they may have been shortsighted in the ways they built out their deployment and the key thing I see a lot of people looking at is - how can I take equipment data, pull it back in an IoT solution and show it in a dashboard," stated Dave McCarthy, Director of Products at Bsquare Corporation, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at @ThingsExpo, held November 1-3, 2016, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA.
Dec. 2, 2016 11:15 PM EST Reads: 848
@DevOpsSummit taking place June 6-8, 2017 at Javits Center, New York City, is co-located with the 20th International Cloud Expo and will feature technical sessions from a rock star conference faculty and the leading industry players in the world. @DevOpsSummit at Cloud Expo New York Call for Papers is now open.
Dec. 2, 2016 10:30 PM EST Reads: 1,718
"We are an all-flash array storage provider but our focus has been on VM-aware storage specifically for virtualized applications," stated Dhiraj Sehgal of Tintri in this SYS-CON.tv interview at 19th Cloud Expo, held November 1-3, 2016, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA.
Dec. 2, 2016 08:30 PM EST Reads: 345
IoT is rapidly changing the way enterprises are using data to improve business decision-making. In order to derive business value, organizations must unlock insights from the data gathered and then act on these. In their session at @ThingsExpo, Eric Hoffman, Vice President at EastBanc Technologies, and Peter Shashkin, Head of Development Department at EastBanc Technologies, discussed how one organization leveraged IoT, cloud technology and data analysis to improve customer experiences and effici...
Dec. 2, 2016 08:30 PM EST Reads: 4,965
Fact is, enterprises have significant legacy voice infrastructure that’s costly to replace with pure IP solutions. How can we bring this analog infrastructure into our shiny new cloud applications? There are proven methods to bind both legacy voice applications and traditional PSTN audio into cloud-based applications and services at a carrier scale. Some of the most successful implementations leverage WebRTC, WebSockets, SIP and other open source technologies. In his session at @ThingsExpo, Da...
Dec. 2, 2016 08:15 PM EST Reads: 1,552
The cloud competition for database hosts is fierce. How do you evaluate a cloud provider for your database platform? In his session at 18th Cloud Expo, Chris Presley, a Solutions Architect at Pythian, gave users a checklist of considerations when choosing a provider. Chris Presley is a Solutions Architect at Pythian. He loves order – making him a premier Microsoft SQL Server expert. Not only has he programmed and administered SQL Server, but he has also shared his expertise and passion with b...
Dec. 2, 2016 07:00 PM EST Reads: 3,909
"IoT is going to be a huge industry with a lot of value for end users, for industries, for consumers, for manufacturers. How can we use cloud to effectively manage IoT applications," stated Ian Khan, Innovation & Marketing Manager at Solgeniakhela, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at @ThingsExpo, held November 3-5, 2015, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA.
Dec. 2, 2016 06:45 PM EST Reads: 3,981
As data explodes in quantity, importance and from new sources, the need for managing and protecting data residing across physical, virtual, and cloud environments grow with it. Managing data includes protecting it, indexing and classifying it for true, long-term management, compliance and E-Discovery. Commvault can ensure this with a single pane of glass solution – whether in a private cloud, a Service Provider delivered public cloud or a hybrid cloud environment – across the heterogeneous enter...
Dec. 2, 2016 06:30 PM EST Reads: 1,475
Without a clear strategy for cost control and an architecture designed with cloud services in mind, costs and operational performance can quickly get out of control. To avoid multiple architectural redesigns requires extensive thought and planning. Boundary (now part of BMC) launched a new public-facing multi-tenant high resolution monitoring service on Amazon AWS two years ago, facing challenges and learning best practices in the early days of the new service. In his session at 19th Cloud Exp...
Dec. 2, 2016 05:15 PM EST Reads: 364
The cloud promises new levels of agility and cost-savings for Big Data, data warehousing and analytics. But it’s challenging to understand all the options – from IaaS and PaaS to newer services like HaaS (Hadoop as a Service) and BDaaS (Big Data as a Service). In her session at @BigDataExpo at @ThingsExpo, Hannah Smalltree, a director at Cazena, provided an educational overview of emerging “as-a-service” options for Big Data in the cloud. This is critical background for IT and data professionals...
Dec. 2, 2016 05:00 PM EST Reads: 4,076
Today we can collect lots and lots of performance data. We build beautiful dashboards and even have fancy query languages to access and transform the data. Still performance data is a secret language only a couple of people understand. The more business becomes digital the more stakeholders are interested in this data including how it relates to business. Some of these people have never used a monitoring tool before. They have a question on their mind like “How is my application doing” but no id...
Dec. 2, 2016 04:45 PM EST Reads: 2,103
@GonzalezCarmen has been ranked the Number One Influencer and @ThingsExpo has been named the Number One Brand in the “M2M 2016: Top 100 Influencers and Brands” by Onalytica. Onalytica analyzed tweets over the last 6 months mentioning the keywords M2M OR “Machine to Machine.” They then identified the top 100 most influential brands and individuals leading the discussion on Twitter.
Dec. 2, 2016 04:45 PM EST Reads: 1,969
More and more brands have jumped on the IoT bandwagon. We have an excess of wearables – activity trackers, smartwatches, smart glasses and sneakers, and more that track seemingly endless datapoints. However, most consumers have no idea what “IoT” means. Creating more wearables that track data shouldn't be the aim of brands; delivering meaningful, tangible relevance to their users should be. We're in a period in which the IoT pendulum is still swinging. Initially, it swung toward "smart for smar...
Dec. 2, 2016 04:15 PM EST Reads: 346
What happens when the different parts of a vehicle become smarter than the vehicle itself? As we move toward the era of smart everything, hundreds of entities in a vehicle that communicate with each other, the vehicle and external systems create a need for identity orchestration so that all entities work as a conglomerate. Much like an orchestra without a conductor, without the ability to secure, control, and connect the link between a vehicle’s head unit, devices, and systems and to manage the ...
Dec. 2, 2016 04:15 PM EST Reads: 363