|By PR Newswire||
|June 7, 2013 06:38 PM EDT||
DALLAS, June 7, 2013 /PRNewswire/ -- The Texas Supreme Court ("Court") has upheld a refund of sales taxes paid by a Ryan client on items resold to the United States government. In Combs v. Health Care Services Corporation, Nos. 11-0283, 11-0652 (Tex., June 7, 2013), the Court ruled that Health Care Services Corporation (HCSC), successor to Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas, Inc., could claim a sale-for-resale exemption on tangible personal property and taxable services purchased to fulfill contracts with the federal government to administer Medicare Part A, Medicare Part B, and the Federal Employees Health Benefit Program ("FEP"). The Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts ("Comptroller") denied HCSC's administrative refund claims, and HCSC subsequently filed suit. Mark W. Eidman and Doug Sigel of the Ryan Law Firm, LLP represented HCSC before the Court.
Ryan analyzed the facts and developed HCSC's theories for recovery during the administrative refund process. HCSC sought refunds of Texas sales and use taxes paid on:
- Allowable Items – tangible personal property, such as office supplies and furniture;
- Capitalized Assets – capital assets that HCSC booked as assets, depreciated, and claimed as depreciation expenses to the federal government;
- Utilities – gas and electricity;
- Leases of office equipment, telephones, postage machines, water coolers, etc.;
- Software/Software Maintenance – licenses to use software and maintenance of software;
- Taxable Services on Tangible Personal Property – repairs of equipment, purchases of burglar or fire alarm services; and
- Maintenance on tangible personal property.
HCSC contended that the foregoing items, on which HCSC paid tax at the time of purchase, were actually resold to the federal government under the Medicare and FEP contracts. The contracts contained title-passage provisions incorporated from the Federal Acquisition Regulations (FAR), which generally provided that items purchased for the performance of the contracts became the property of the federal government upon delivery to HCSC. The Court upheld the sale-for-resale exemption on purchases of tangible personal property and taxable services but denied the exemption for leases of tangible personal property.
First, the Court held that HCSC was entitled to the sale-for-resale exemption on purchases of tangible personal property that was automatically transferred to the federal government under the title passage provisions. The Comptroller presented the Court with a novel interpretation of the "essence of the transaction" test, contending that the sale-for-resale exemption did not apply because HCSC's "primary purpose" in buying property was to use it in the performance of nontaxable services and not to resell it in the form or condition in which it was acquired. The Court rejected this argument because it is not supported by the plain language of the statute.
Furthermore, the Court reaffirmed its earlier decision in Day & Zimmerman, Inc. v. Calvert, 519 S.W.2d 106 (Tex. 1975). The Court held that the title transfer provisions at issue in Day & Zimmerman are indistinguishable from those in the present case and that subsequent changes in the law neither modified nor abrogated Day & Zimmerman. The Court held that "Day & Zimmerman cuts squarely in HCSC's favor" and "stands for the proposition that automatic title transfer upon purchase qualifies for the sale-for-resale exemption."
The Court rejected the Comptroller's argument that "absurd" consequences would flow from a ruling in favor of HCSC. The Comptroller pointed out that a provider of a taxable service may issue a resale certificate only for the purchase of tangible personal property that will be transferred to the care, custody, and control of the purchaser of the service, whereas the provider of a nontaxable service (such as HCSC) could claim the exemption under automatic title transfer provisions in its contracts. First, the Court noted that "absurdity" is an issue only if a statute is ambiguous and that there is nothing "absurd" about treating providers of taxable and nontaxable services differently. The Court wrote that even "odd" or unexpected results do not compel it to rewrite an unambiguous law. The Court said that the Legislature has had decades since Day & Zimmerman to close this alleged "loophole" but has not done so.
Next, the Court held that HCSC's purchases of taxable services also qualified for the sale-for-resale exemption. The Comptroller argued that the title transfer provisions applied only to tangible personal property. The Court responded that HCSC acquired taxable services and resold them to the government "by directing that they be performed on the government's behalf with the purpose of receiving reimbursement and compensation (consideration) from the government…" Such services were resold "in the form or condition" in which they were acquired. Therefore, they qualified for the exemption under the plain language of the statute.
The Court denied the sale-for-resale exemption for HCSC's leases of tangible personal property. Although the Court acknowledged that a lease of property for the purpose of re-leasing it would qualify for the sale-for-resale exemption, it held that there was no evidence that HCSC re-leased property to the federal government. Using the property to perform nontaxable services under a federal contract was not the same as "formally re-leasing" the property to the government. The subsequent transfer of leased property to a new contractor after the expiration of HCSC's contract was insufficient to establish that HCSC originally leased the property for the purpose of re-leasing it, as required by the exemption.
Finally, the Comptroller argued that HCSC could not obtain a refund because the government reimbursed HCSC for the sales taxes it paid to its suppliers. The Comptroller relied on Tex. Tax Code section 111.104(f), which provides that "[n]o taxes…may be refunded to a person who has collected the taxes from another person unless the person has refunded all the taxes and interest to the person from whom the taxes were collected." The Court held that "reimbursement" and "collection" of taxes are two different things, and HCSC did not "collect" taxes from the federal government within the meaning of the statute.
The Court remanded the case to the trial court for entry of judgment based upon these holdings. At press time, it was not known whether the Comptroller would ask the Court to reconsider.
Ryan is an award-winning global tax services firm, with the largest indirect tax practice in North America and the seventh largest corporate tax practice in the United States. Headquartered in Dallas, Texas, the Firm provides a comprehensive range of state, local, federal, and international tax advisory and consulting services on a multi-jurisdictional basis, including audit defense, tax recovery, credits and incentives, tax process improvement and automation, tax appeals, tax compliance, and strategic planning. Ryan is a three-time recipient of the International Service Excellence Award from the Customer Service Institute of America (CSIA) for its commitment to world-class client service. Empowered by the dynamic myRyan work environment, which is widely recognized as the most innovative in the tax services industry, Ryan's multi-disciplinary team of more than 1,600 professionals and associates serves over 9,000 clients in 40 countries, including many of the world's most prominent Global 5000 companies. More information about Ryan can be found at www.ryan.com.
TECHNICAL INFORMATION CONTACTS:
Randy W. Donald
Ginny Buckner Kissling
John D. Christian
SOURCE Ryan, LLC
If you’re responsible for an application that depends on the data or functionality of various IoT endpoints – either sensors or devices – your brand reputation depends on the security, reliability, and compliance of its many integrated parts. If your application fails to deliver the expected business results, your customers and partners won't care if that failure stems from the code you developed or from a component that you integrated. What can you do to ensure that the endpoints work as expect...
Sep. 24, 2016 04:30 PM EDT Reads: 1,473
Traditional on-premises data centers have long been the domain of modern data platforms like Apache Hadoop, meaning companies who build their business on public cloud were challenged to run Big Data processing and analytics at scale. But recent advancements in Hadoop performance, security, and most importantly cloud-native integrations, are giving organizations the ability to truly gain value from all their data. In his session at 19th Cloud Expo, David Tishgart, Director of Product Marketing ...
Sep. 24, 2016 04:30 PM EDT Reads: 1,662
Data is an unusual currency; it is not restricted by the same transactional limitations as money or people. In fact, the more that you leverage your data across multiple business use cases, the more valuable it becomes to the organization. And the same can be said about the organization’s analytics. In his session at 19th Cloud Expo, Bill Schmarzo, CTO for the Big Data Practice at EMC, will introduce a methodology for capturing, enriching and sharing data (and analytics) across the organizati...
Sep. 24, 2016 04:15 PM EDT Reads: 1,532
While DevOps promises a better and tighter integration among an organization’s development and operation teams and transforms an application life cycle into a continual deployment, Chef and Azure together provides a speedy, cost-effective and highly scalable vehicle for realizing the business values of this transformation. In his session at @DevOpsSummit at 19th Cloud Expo, Yung Chou, a Technology Evangelist at Microsoft, will present a unique opportunity to witness how Chef and Azure work tog...
Sep. 24, 2016 04:00 PM EDT Reads: 1,479
The vision of a connected smart home is becoming reality with the application of integrated wireless technologies in devices and appliances. The use of standardized and TCP/IP networked wireless technologies in line-powered and battery operated sensors and controls has led to the adoption of radios in the 2.4GHz band, including Wi-Fi, BT/BLE and 802.15.4 applied ZigBee and Thread. This is driving the need for robust wireless coexistence for multiple radios to ensure throughput performance and th...
Sep. 24, 2016 03:45 PM EDT Reads: 1,397
Information technology is an industry that has always experienced change, and the dramatic change sweeping across the industry today could not be truthfully described as the first time we've seen such widespread change impacting customer investments. However, the rate of the change, and the potential outcomes from today's digital transformation has the distinct potential to separate the industry into two camps: Organizations that see the change coming, embrace it, and successful leverage it; and...
Sep. 24, 2016 03:00 PM EDT Reads: 1,012
I'm a lonely sensor. I spend all day telling the world how I'm feeling, but none of the other sensors seem to care. I want to be connected. I want to build relationships with other sensors to be more useful for my human. I want my human to understand that when my friends next door are too hot for a while, I'll soon be flaming. And when all my friends go outside without me, I may be left behind. Don't just log my data; use the relationship graph. In his session at @ThingsExpo, Ryan Boyd, Engi...
Sep. 24, 2016 02:15 PM EDT Reads: 1,178
The Internet of Things can drive efficiency for airlines and airports. In their session at @ThingsExpo, Shyam Varan Nath, Principal Architect with GE, and Sudip Majumder, senior director of development at Oracle, will discuss the technical details of the connected airline baggage and related social media solutions. These IoT applications will enhance travelers' journey experience and drive efficiency for the airlines and the airports. The session will include a working demo and a technical d...
Sep. 24, 2016 02:00 PM EDT Reads: 1,615
SYS-CON Events announced today that China Unicom will exhibit at the 19th International Cloud Expo, which will take place on November 1–3, 2016, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA. China United Network Communications Group Co. Ltd ("China Unicom") was officially established in 2009 on the basis of the merger of former China Netcom and former China Unicom. China Unicom mainly operates a full range of telecommunications services including mobile broadband (GSM, WCDMA, LTE F...
Sep. 24, 2016 01:30 PM EDT Reads: 1,668
Enterprise IT has been in the era of Hybrid Cloud for some time now. But it seems most conversations about Hybrid are focused on integrating AWS, Microsoft Azure, or Google ECM into existing on-premises systems. Where is all the Private Cloud? What do technology providers need to do to make their offerings more compelling? How should enterprise IT executives and buyers define their focus, needs, and roadmap, and communicate that clearly to the providers?
Sep. 24, 2016 01:00 PM EDT Reads: 1,467
The Transparent Cloud-computing Consortium (abbreviation: T-Cloud Consortium) will conduct research activities into changes in the computing model as a result of collaboration between "device" and "cloud" and the creation of new value and markets through organic data processing High speed and high quality networks, and dramatic improvements in computer processing capabilities, have greatly changed the nature of applications and made the storing and processing of data on the network commonplace.
Sep. 24, 2016 12:00 PM EDT Reads: 724
SYS-CON Events announced today that SoftLayer, an IBM Company, has been named “Gold Sponsor” of SYS-CON's 18th Cloud Expo, which will take place on June 7-9, 2016, at the Javits Center in New York, New York. SoftLayer, an IBM Company, provides cloud infrastructure as a service from a growing number of data centers and network points of presence around the world. SoftLayer’s customers range from Web startups to global enterprises.
Sep. 24, 2016 12:00 PM EDT Reads: 722
Digital innovation is the next big wave of business transformation based on digital technologies of which IoT and Big Data are key components, For example: Business boundary innovation is a challenge to excavate third-party business value using IoT and BigData, like Nest Business structure innovation may propose re-building business structure from scratch, as Uber does in the taxicab industry The social model innovation is also a big challenge to the new social architecture with the design fr...
Sep. 24, 2016 11:45 AM EDT Reads: 1,014
Fact is, enterprises have significant legacy voice infrastructure that’s costly to replace with pure IP solutions. How can we bring this analog infrastructure into our shiny new cloud applications? There are proven methods to bind both legacy voice applications and traditional PSTN audio into cloud-based applications and services at a carrier scale. Some of the most successful implementations leverage WebRTC, WebSockets, SIP and other open source technologies. In his session at @ThingsExpo, Da...
Sep. 24, 2016 11:15 AM EDT Reads: 1,444
In his session at @DevOpsSummit at 19th Cloud Expo, Robert Doyle, lead architect at eCube Systems, will examine the issues and need for an agile infrastructure and show the advantages of capturing developer knowledge in an exportable file for migration into production. He will introduce the use of NXTmonitor, a next-generation DevOps tool that captures application environments, dependencies and start/stop procedures in a portable configuration file with an easy-to-use GUI. In addition to captu...
Sep. 24, 2016 11:00 AM EDT Reads: 940